Business growth beyond sales and marketing - Accelerate Business Group


Creating a Profitable Business and Lifelong Customers




A simple, easy, and obvious way to avoid being a commodity

By Jim Logan • Jun 27th, 2007 • Category: Branding, PR, and Advertising

The simplest way to avoid becoming a commodity – subjecting you to price comparisons and low to non-existent customer loyalty – is not to allow yourself to be common. The secret is obvious - make yourself an orange to compare to the apples in your market.

But it’s not always simple, easy, or as obvious as it should be. Or is it?

You can’t be in much more a commodity business than whiteboards. I’m talking about the boards littering the walls of offices around the world – capturing dry erased plans, projects, priorities, and wild ideas of employees and business leaders alike.

There aren’t a lot of options with whiteboard – size is the primary consideration when purchasing. A try to hold markers is about the only variable. Accessories are pretty much limited to markers and erasers. Magnet boards offer a choice of sorts for magnets. For the most part, we buy whiteboards based on price per size. They’re a commodity.

Or are they?

A StartupJournal article showcases a tiny company named Magnatag Visible Systems. Magnatag is an orange in the world of apples filled whiteboards. They’ve separated themselves from the commodity market they exist in. What they do is simple, easy, and obvious – using magnets and grids, they make whiteboards for specific purposes and uses.

The doctors on NBC’s “ER” series used a Magnatag on set to keep track of patients. This year, the New Orleans Saints mapped NFL draft picks on a Magnatag. A Colorado sheriff’s posse swears by their Magnatag for plotting search-and-rescue mountain missions.

If you want to know what an orange looks like, here’s a great example. The founder of Magnatag describes his business like this: Our boards are problem-solving devices — they are aspirins for people’s headaches.

That’s an orange.

And the result is Magnatag commands up to $1500 per board, with systems offered up to $10K+! Systems of whiteboards???? You can’t get much more an orange than this.

Unless you like competing on price and low margins, the benefits of not being a commodity are great. And it can be simple, easy, and obvious. The trick is to focus on your customer, think as they do, and solve the problem or create the opportunity they’re working to achieve. Then have the courage to act, test, and adjust to feedback.

I spoke to the Virtual Assistance Chamber of Commerce last month about the dangers of being a commodity and ways to be an orange and avoid competing on price. The host told me it was the most attended teleconference they’ve held. It’s a good topic.

Is commoditization and its effects a concern in your business? Are you competing in a market driven by price, spec sheets, and everyone looks alike? Would you like to learn more about ways to avoid being a commodity, reducing price pressure, and maintaining – if not increasing – margins?

Please let me know your thoughts on this topic and your interest in discussing it more on this site.

Powered by Gregarious (42)
Share This Post

Jim Logan is the founder of JS Logan, a B2B lead generation and sales acceleration company. Click Here and discover what makes JS Logan different from other B2B complex sales and marketing firms. If you enjoyed this post, please Subscribe. It's the best way to make sure you don't miss a single tip or how-to shared on this site.
Email this author | All posts by Jim Logan

3 Responses »

  1. Trying to visit their website gives me this: “We appreciate your interest in viewing our Magnatag Visible Systems website, however we have designed it for viewers in the United States and Canada only, the marketplace we serve. ”
    What kind of idiocy is that?
    I hereby vow to never ever use a Magnatab, let alone buy one, even if they should ever become available in Europe.
    People should start to understand what the Internet is.

  2. Hi Ergin! That’s incredible! I’ve never heard of such a thing. Do you encounter that very often? I’d think not…certainly not in 2007!

    Even if they only serve the US and Canada markets…I don’t see a reason to do that - given their product maybe language is the reason.

    It’s shortsighted and limiting to their business.

  3. Hi Jim, I have never encountered anything like this in the last 8 to 10 years.

    To give them credit, the page that I get also offers the possibility to “submit an access request to view our website” by filling in a web form with my contact information.

    However, that prevents people from just giving their site a cursory look while surfing the web and taking note of their product as the coolproduct that it probably is. Very short-sighted indeed.

    Maybe they are trying to to assess their market potential in Europe by collecting the address information of (hopefully) serious potential customers.

    I just felt they disrupted my “surfing” experience though.

Leave a Reply